Fairy Tail Wiki
Fairy Tail Wiki
m (Evanalmighty moved page Fairy Tail Wiki talk:Main Page to Talk:Main Page over redirect)
(289 intermediate revisions by 79 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{TalkPage|1}}
+
{{TalkPage|1|2}}
   
  +
==Removal of the Reddit Discord==
==Guild Portal==
 
  +
I'm writing this as a form of formality and documentation on the removal of the fairy tail reddit discord from the fairy tail wiki. Based on recent events, We are now ending our affiliation with the Fairy Tail reddit discord due to events brought up by [[User:Miskos3]] as quoted below.
{{Discussion Closed|result=Pending.}}
 
i think we should add a portal on the main page for the guilds that play major parts in fairy tail's plot. it should include fairy tail, sabertooth, lamia scale, blue peagsus, quatro cerberus, mermaid heel, raven tail, phantom lord, Crime Sorcière, Oración Seis, Grimoire Heart, and Fairy Tail (Edolas). [[User:DalekSupreme13|DalekSupreme13]] 08:10, June 14, 2012 (UTC)
 
   
  +
"Hello, so there has been a bit of, um, situation with the whole affiliation thing to the FT reddit and their discord. Basically, Michelle became a moderator in that discord, but ended up being constantly bullied by the rest of their staff and/or other people. Because of that, she decided to leave that server. Since as far as I'm concerned, I considered her as sort of a FT wiki representative in this whole affiliation thing, and in any kind of partnership, it looks quite bad to treat a person you're dealing with in such a manner."
{{Neutral}} I don't really think that it would look great if we add another portal. Though maybe the [[Project:Dragons of Design|Dragons of Design]] can think of a way to make it work? xD {{User:B j/Sig3|08:29,6/14/2012}}
 
   
  +
When the idea of implementing the reddit discord in the fairy tail wiki was proposed by [[User:AstonishingSpiderMan]], they've mentioned these "Ultimately like I said, I want to unite discord, reddit, and the ft wikia together where the fandom could coexist and prosper and thrive with our love for Fairy Tail."
How do i contact them?[[User:DalekSupreme13|DalekSupreme13]] 09:04, June 14, 2012 (UTC)
 
   
  +
We believe that the discord staffs and members bullying someone from the fairy tail wiki side does not fit with what was promised to us by [[User:AstonishingSpiderMan]]. This kind of treatment does not support the idea of "unity between reddit, discord and coexistence" As admins we have taken an executive decision to terminate the said partnership. {{User:LightningGeist/Sig1}} 11:18, June 6, 2020 (UTC)
:Here's their [[Project talk:Dragons of Design|talk page]]. You can also contact the "leader", [[User:Rauleli|Rauleli]]. {{User:B j/Sig3|09:06,6/14/2012}}
 
   
  +
A shame that this happened, any word from AstonishingSpiderMan about this?{{User: Animaltamer7/Sig13a}}11:29, June 6, 2020 (UTC)
Actually, we're going to hold off on this for a while. I plan on having the Dragons of Design POSSIBLY redesign the Main Page. And when we do the redesign we'll add in a guild portal but a guild portal wouldn't look good with the current design. {{User:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Sig8}}15:05,6/14/2012
 
   
  +
None so far, but given that the people from the fairy tail wiki are already in the minority within the discord its very likely that the majority of users will stick with their fellow reddit discord members. Bullying a moderator to the point of them leaving the discord server already means that bullying is agreed upon by a lot of users and such thing were allowed to happen by the rest of the discord. Even if the bullying was denounced by [[User:AstonishingSpiderMan]] it doesn't change the fact that such thing happened, and it's very unlikely that they can force the discord members to change their ways either.
==Erza Profile Pic on Start Site==
 
{{Discussion Closed|result=Picture would not change.}}
 
What's about a new Erza Profile Pic on the Site ? Lucy already has a X791 Pic.
 
   
  +
So it's really unfortunate that the situation led to this and promoting a place where such bullying happens is not what we were hoping to accomplish in the said partnership and it is definitely not the place where we would encourage the young and new fans of the series visiting the wiki to be exposed to. {{User:LightningGeist/Sig1}} 12:07, June 6, 2020 (UTC)
How's this:
 
   
  +
Michelle is lying, I have done nothing but treat everyone with respect. She has admitted to accusing mods of hating her but subsequently admitted to them doing a fair job of moderating. She even made up with a mod she accused of hating her. Additionally, she even stepped down from the server when she was mod because of reasons I did not agree with. Ultimately, I am saddened that this has even happened. We all worked hard to make this partnership happen, I have even been working on incentivicizing users (via gift cards, or other rewards) to edit and help in the wikia but if you wish to remove the affiliation then I respect the decision. I disagree vehemently but it is not my decision to make. I am honestly tired of this from her, she has an issue she then threatens to get the affiliation to be removed, she has to have her way, and it's frustrating. I have been respectful, I have tried doing something for the entire community but I will not be held hostage by her. I worked something out with you. Uncool is still there and still comments and interacts, Davjac who she considers a close friend doesn't agree with the accusation either. The records are there, she wasn't mistreated, she didn't like that there was a change implemented so she cried foul. - Spider-Man
Old:
 
  +
[[User:AstonishingSpiderMan|AstonishingSpiderMan]] ([[User talk:AstonishingSpiderMan|talk]]) 23:57, June 6, 2020 (UTC)
[[File:Erza_prof.jpg|100px]]
 
   
  +
I want to start off saying that in no way do users in the discord bully anyone. There is friendly banter yes, but to say we bullied someone into the point of leaving is 100% false. Next, Michelle and I are friends and in no way am I here to talk bad about her or anyone else for that matter. I am here to say yes, there were problems between people in the server, but it was never bullying. People didn't get along all that well sometimes and after some changes were made there were some issues that happened. Again, I am friends with Michelle and all the mods as well. I understand people were unhappy and were having a hard time that is literally just people not getting along all the time. Neither side was bullying the other. I am someone who tends to stay neutral which I will do now but really wanted to give another POV on this issue. I disagree with the statement that she was bullied out of the server 100% again and I do recognize there were issues between users which is bound to happen. The community and server are a good place and people are always having fun for the most part in their discussions and interactions with each other. I don't think it’s fair to punish everyone else revoking the affiliation over something where both parties were at fault for not getting along not bullying. Obviously, you probably don't care about my opinion or pov on the matter, but this is what happened. Not everyone is going to agree or get along all the time and it’s unfair to punish everyone else because of problems a few had with each other. Also, the post makes it seem like we are all bullies and rude which is not the case at all. These people are friends of mine on both sides. [[User:Taillee|Taillee]] ([[User talk:Taillee|talk]]) 01:31, June 7, 2020 (UTC)
New:
 
[[File:133_-_Erza_in_X791_proposal2.png|100px]]
 
   
  +
I wasn't going to make a statement because after i left the server that was the end of it for me. but i do want to clear some things up. the issues I had with the server stemmed from a select few individuals, and in no way reflects on the community as a whole. I won't be calling out or naming said individuals because honestly there isn't a need to - i still hold dearly to me many people from the server, a majority of which are part of the staff. the term bullying is not the most appropriate word for the conflicts that had occurred as i am not someone who is without fault. Nor was it a manner of outright harassment either.
   
  +
However, i was not respected there, myself as well as many other people from the server have voiced the same opinions and thoughts. I was treated in a hurtful manner by people i considered friends to me or people who i had tried to make amends with.
Think about it :)
 
   
  +
if there is one thing i pride myself on, it is that i am a genuine person, it may appear as though i love to create drama but it is rather that i am someone who is not easily pushed around and i will always stand up for myself when i'm being treated poorly. I think a lot of people from the wiki could agree with that, as well as people from the server. Leaving the server was not a decision i took lightly and it is one i had sat on for a while and it is one that i didn't want to make, but ultimately i felt extremely uncomfortable remaining in a place where i felt nothing but hostility.
[[User:MavisV.|MavisV.]] 13:24, June 14, 2012 (UTC)
 
   
  +
that's all i'm going to say on the matter because i have no need to drag this on any further, the decision to remove the affiliation was not a decision made or pushed solely by myself but was discussed by the admins themselves.
:We've already had a discussion about this and chose not to use the pic. {{User:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Sig8}}15:06,6/14/2012
 
   
  +
[[User:Michelle Hyena|Michelle Hyena]] ([[User talk:Michelle Hyena|talk]]) 02:10, June 7, 2020 (UTC)
== Official Volume 19 translations ==
 
 
Kodansha has released Volume 19 in English, and the following names have been given new spellings:
 
 
*[[Roubaul]] is now '''Robaul'''.
 
*[[Klodoa]] is now '''Kurodoa'''.
 
 
Also, still waiting on the confirmation that the name "[[Kinana|Cuberos]]" has been changed to '''Cubellios''' in Volume 18. [[User:Immblueversion|Immblueversion]] 01:13, June 21, 2012 (UTC)
 
 
== Manga title on Main Page ==
 
 
Ehh.. Anyone noticed that manga title is still form chapter 289 while summary is form 290?
 
 
I'm writing my complain here because I can't fix it myself...
 
Veldirn 11:20, July 07, 2012 (UTC)
 
 
==We should change Gray and Jellal's profile pics!==
 
 
I think maybe we should change the profile pics of Gray and Jellal on this site and try more new and updated pics.I think we should change these two because they are two of the most attractive male characters in Fairy Tail and their current pics don't really show that off!Thanks!--[[Special:Contributions/210.4.65.12|210.4.65.12]] 11:42, August 24, 2012 (UTC)
 
 
== Character Profile Portals ==
 
{{Discussion Closed|result=The change will not be made.}}
 
I don't recall any discussion that brings this to mind, so I'll just announce it here.
 
 
From what's seen on the Main Page, there are two sections consisting of six portals each linking to different characters from the series. It appears that it's Protagonists on the top half while there are Antagonists on the lower half. Since that ''appears'' to be the case, why is it that [[Ikaruga]] is featured? Compared to the others (perhaps [[Ultear]] as well), she's a very minor character who's made significant appearances towards the latter half of one arc. I would propose that she be replaced with someone such as [[Brain]]/[[Zero]]. He is a major antagonist during the [[Oración Seis arc]] and I believe he would be better suited than Ikaruga to be on the Main Page in that particular area.<br>{{User:Glass Heart/Sig|07:35,12/29/2012}}
 
 
{{Support}} Yeah... I was looking at that, too. Brain/Zero is a good choice, seeing as the antagonists are listed after the protagonist, and Brain being the main antagonist in the OS arc. Sleep time ( ._.)~.{{User:Omega natsu2/Sig2}} 07:40, December 29, 2012 (UTC)
 
 
{{Support}} - for Ikaruga's change. I do remember at one point that it was said there needed to be some sort of a male-female ratio though. Angel is far more significant than Ikaruga... {{User:Umnei/Sig1}} 08:28, December 29, 2012 (UTC)
 
 
{{Support}} Agree with your idea. Change Ikaruga to Brain/Zero since he is the main antagonist of OS arc. {{User:Rifatmfarid/Sig1}} 08:50, December 29, 2012 (UTC)
 
 
{{Neutral}} Erm I dunno, I don't really mind her being there, if anything, she should be replaced by another - female - antagonist.. {{User:Miskos3/Sig1}} 09:41, December 29, 2012 (UTC)
 
 
{{Support}} <s>Alright, as long as Jellal won't be removed in there >:D</s> Yeah, Brain's better to be there. {{User:RedFemaleKnight/Sig8|6:25PM, December 29, 2012}}
 
 
{{Neutral}} The Main Page will be redesigned by the DOD... Changes here won't mean much... {{User:Guilherme Abe/Sig1}} 12:32,12/29/2012
 
 
{{Oppose}} If it's going to be replaced, it has to be another female antagonist in order to keep the male-to-female ration. And as Herme said, the DOD is going to redesign it later anyway. {{User:Rauleli/Sig6}} 18:28, December 29, 2012 (UTC)
 
 
Sorry you guys, but I'm going to have to close this vote. We have Ikaruga because, as Reli and Nei-chan have pointed out, there is a specific male-to-female ratio that must be maintained. And the last time I checked, Brain/Zero is not a female. >_> Ikaruga can be exchanged, but she can only be exchanged by another female antagonist. {{User:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Sig8}}19:38,12/29/2012
 
:Angel :P {{User:Rauleli/Sig6}} 19:40, December 29, 2012 (UTC)
 
 
::She would be a good replacement. Especially since she made a reappearances. :P {{User:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Sig8}}19:43,12/29/2012
 
 
:::[[Angel]] for now and once [[Minerva]] is colored, can she be included there also? Just an early proposal. Hihi. {{User:Kokorochas/Sig2}} 02:31, December 30, 2012 (UTC)
 
::::Minerva might go up there at some point since the ratio is not complete yet and since I couldn't find any female antagonist that I thought were good enough. :/ {{User:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Sig8}}03:13,12/30/2012
 
{{Support}} Agree with what you said and I was thinking Mirajane should replaced with Lisanna instead since shes been part of the influence due to her "death" {{User:ShinShinTo/Sig1}} 02:43, December 30, 2012 (UTC)
 
:Nah! Mira is far too epic and relevant than Lisanna. {{User:Kokorochas/Sig2}} 02:47, December 30, 2012 (UTC)
 
:Mirajane will not be replaced by Lisanna. {{User:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Sig8}}03:13,12/30/2012
 

Revision as of 02:10, 7 June 2020

Skip to Table of Contents
Wiki

This is the talk page for the article "Main Page".

  • This space is for discussing changes to the article. General discussion about the subject belongs in forums, and direct all questions to our Chat or Blogs.
  • Put new text under old text. Click here to start a new topic.
  • Please remember to stay civil and sign all of your comments with four tildes (~~~~).

Removal of the Reddit Discord

I'm writing this as a form of formality and documentation on the removal of the fairy tail reddit discord from the fairy tail wiki. Based on recent events, We are now ending our affiliation with the Fairy Tail reddit discord due to events brought up by User:Miskos3 as quoted below.

"Hello, so there has been a bit of, um, situation with the whole affiliation thing to the FT reddit and their discord. Basically, Michelle became a moderator in that discord, but ended up being constantly bullied by the rest of their staff and/or other people. Because of that, she decided to leave that server. Since as far as I'm concerned, I considered her as sort of a FT wiki representative in this whole affiliation thing, and in any kind of partnership, it looks quite bad to treat a person you're dealing with in such a manner."

When the idea of implementing the reddit discord in the fairy tail wiki was proposed by User:AstonishingSpiderMan, they've mentioned these "Ultimately like I said, I want to unite discord, reddit, and the ft wikia together where the fandom could coexist and prosper and thrive with our love for Fairy Tail."

We believe that the discord staffs and members bullying someone from the fairy tail wiki side does not fit with what was promised to us by User:AstonishingSpiderMan. This kind of treatment does not support the idea of "unity between reddit, discord and coexistence" As admins we have taken an executive decision to terminate the said partnership. LightningGeistRead about Laxus? 11:18, June 6, 2020 (UTC)

A shame that this happened, any word from AstonishingSpiderMan about this?Ophiuchus in ECS arc no bgAnimaltamer7Ophiuchus11:29, June 6, 2020 (UTC)

None so far, but given that the people from the fairy tail wiki are already in the minority within the discord its very likely that the majority of users will stick with their fellow reddit discord members. Bullying a moderator to the point of them leaving the discord server already means that bullying is agreed upon by a lot of users and such thing were allowed to happen by the rest of the discord. Even if the bullying was denounced by User:AstonishingSpiderMan it doesn't change the fact that such thing happened, and it's very unlikely that they can force the discord members to change their ways either.

So it's really unfortunate that the situation led to this and promoting a place where such bullying happens is not what we were hoping to accomplish in the said partnership and it is definitely not the place where we would encourage the young and new fans of the series visiting the wiki to be exposed to. LightningGeistRead about Laxus? 12:07, June 6, 2020 (UTC)

Michelle is lying, I have done nothing but treat everyone with respect. She has admitted to accusing mods of hating her but subsequently admitted to them doing a fair job of moderating. She even made up with a mod she accused of hating her. Additionally, she even stepped down from the server when she was mod because of reasons I did not agree with. Ultimately, I am saddened that this has even happened. We all worked hard to make this partnership happen, I have even been working on incentivicizing users (via gift cards, or other rewards) to edit and help in the wikia but if you wish to remove the affiliation then I respect the decision. I disagree vehemently but it is not my decision to make. I am honestly tired of this from her, she has an issue she then threatens to get the affiliation to be removed, she has to have her way, and it's frustrating. I have been respectful, I have tried doing something for the entire community but I will not be held hostage by her. I worked something out with you. Uncool is still there and still comments and interacts, Davjac who she considers a close friend doesn't agree with the accusation either. The records are there, she wasn't mistreated, she didn't like that there was a change implemented so she cried foul. - Spider-Man AstonishingSpiderMan (talk) 23:57, June 6, 2020 (UTC)

I want to start off saying that in no way do users in the discord bully anyone. There is friendly banter yes, but to say we bullied someone into the point of leaving is 100% false. Next, Michelle and I are friends and in no way am I here to talk bad about her or anyone else for that matter. I am here to say yes, there were problems between people in the server, but it was never bullying. People didn't get along all that well sometimes and after some changes were made there were some issues that happened. Again, I am friends with Michelle and all the mods as well. I understand people were unhappy and were having a hard time that is literally just people not getting along all the time. Neither side was bullying the other. I am someone who tends to stay neutral which I will do now but really wanted to give another POV on this issue. I disagree with the statement that she was bullied out of the server 100% again and I do recognize there were issues between users which is bound to happen. The community and server are a good place and people are always having fun for the most part in their discussions and interactions with each other. I don't think it’s fair to punish everyone else revoking the affiliation over something where both parties were at fault for not getting along not bullying. Obviously, you probably don't care about my opinion or pov on the matter, but this is what happened. Not everyone is going to agree or get along all the time and it’s unfair to punish everyone else because of problems a few had with each other. Also, the post makes it seem like we are all bullies and rude which is not the case at all. These people are friends of mine on both sides. Taillee (talk) 01:31, June 7, 2020 (UTC)

I wasn't going to make a statement because after i left the server that was the end of it for me. but i do want to clear some things up. the issues I had with the server stemmed from a select few individuals, and in no way reflects on the community as a whole. I won't be calling out or naming said individuals because honestly there isn't a need to - i still hold dearly to me many people from the server, a majority of which are part of the staff. the term bullying is not the most appropriate word for the conflicts that had occurred as i am not someone who is without fault. Nor was it a manner of outright harassment either.

However, i was not respected there, myself as well as many other people from the server have voiced the same opinions and thoughts. I was treated in a hurtful manner by people i considered friends to me or people who i had tried to make amends with.

if there is one thing i pride myself on, it is that i am a genuine person, it may appear as though i love to create drama but it is rather that i am someone who is not easily pushed around and i will always stand up for myself when i'm being treated poorly. I think a lot of people from the wiki could agree with that, as well as people from the server. Leaving the server was not a decision i took lightly and it is one i had sat on for a while and it is one that i didn't want to make, but ultimately i felt extremely uncomfortable remaining in a place where i felt nothing but hostility.

that's all i'm going to say on the matter because i have no need to drag this on any further, the decision to remove the affiliation was not a decision made or pushed solely by myself but was discussed by the admins themselves.

Michelle Hyena (talk) 02:10, June 7, 2020 (UTC)