Fairy Tail Wiki
Fairy Tail Wiki
(343 intermediate revisions by 94 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{TalkPage|1}}
+
{{TalkPage|1|2}}
   
  +
==Removal of the Reddit Discord==
== why are they even there? ==
 
  +
I'm writing this as a form of formality and documentation on the removal of the fairy tail reddit discord from the fairy tail wiki. Based on recent events, We are now ending our affiliation with the Fairy Tail reddit discord due to events brought up by [[User:Miskos3]] as quoted below.
Why are hades,ultear,knightwalker,azuma,and jose on the main page under that welcome to the fairy tail wikia thing? their not even main characters. why not exchange them with makarov or some actually top protagonists? --[[User:Imhungry4444| Troll King Imhungry4444]] 23:35, October 10, 2011 (UTC)
 
   
  +
"Hello, so there has been a bit of, um, situation with the whole affiliation thing to the FT reddit and their discord. Basically, Michelle became a moderator in that discord, but ended up being constantly bullied by the rest of their staff and/or other people. Because of that, she decided to leave that server. Since as far as I'm concerned, I considered her as sort of a FT wiki representative in this whole affiliation thing, and in any kind of partnership, it looks quite bad to treat a person you're dealing with in such a manner."
Becuase the top row displays protagonists and the bottom row displays antagonists. {{User:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Sig3|23:36,10/10/2011}}
 
   
  +
When the idea of implementing the reddit discord in the fairy tail wiki was proposed by [[User:AstonishingSpiderMan]], they've mentioned these "Ultimately like I said, I want to unite discord, reddit, and the ft wikia together where the fandom could coexist and prosper and thrive with our love for Fairy Tail."
ah well that makes sense but idk if azuma or knightwalker should be there. why not brain and faust? --[[User:Imhungry4444| Troll King Imhungry4444]] 01:11, October 11, 2011 (UTC)
 
   
  +
We believe that the discord staffs and members bullying someone from the fairy tail wiki side does not fit with what was promised to us by [[User:AstonishingSpiderMan]]. This kind of treatment does not support the idea of "unity between reddit, discord and coexistence" As admins we have taken an executive decision to terminate the said partnership. {{User:LightningGeist/Sig1}} 11:18, June 6, 2020 (UTC)
True, both of them were the leaders of their respective arcs, I'll trade them now. {{User:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Sig3|01:19,10/11/2011}}
 
   
  +
A shame that this happened, any word from AstonishingSpiderMan about this?{{User: Animaltamer7/Sig13a}}11:29, June 6, 2020 (UTC)
== Funimation dub episode titles and character quotations ==
 
I was thinking, now that the Fairy Tail anime is being dubbed by Funimation, should the episode titles be changed to correspond to the official English title cards as translated and provided by the Funimation release? For example:
 
   
  +
None so far, but given that the people from the fairy tail wiki are already in the minority within the discord its very likely that the majority of users will stick with their fellow reddit discord members. Bullying a moderator to the point of them leaving the discord server already means that bullying is agreed upon by a lot of users and such thing were allowed to happen by the rest of the discord. Even if the bullying was denounced by [[User:AstonishingSpiderMan]] it doesn't change the fact that such thing happened, and it's very unlikely that they can force the discord members to change their ways either.
#"[[Fairy Tail (Episode)]]" --> "The Fairy Tail"
 
#"[[The Fire Dragon, the Monkey, and the Ox]]" --> "Fire Dragon, Monkey, and Bull"
 
#"[[Infiltrate! The Everlue Mansion!]]" --> "Infiltrate the Everlue Mansion"
 
#"[[DEAR KABY]]" --> "Dear Kaby"
 
   
  +
So it's really unfortunate that the situation led to this and promoting a place where such bullying happens is not what we were hoping to accomplish in the said partnership and it is definitely not the place where we would encourage the young and new fans of the series visiting the wiki to be exposed to. {{User:LightningGeist/Sig1}} 12:07, June 6, 2020 (UTC)
If for whatever reason people may choose the unofficial, "literal" translations of the episode titles to be kept (for example, the title of episode 3 contains punctuations that are removed from the Funimation translation), could there possibly be an additional section in the episode template featuring such a translation? And while the remaining episodes uploaded online by Funimation do feature English translations via subtitles, I am more in favor of waiting until those episodes have official English title cards, but only if this change is accepted.
 
   
  +
Michelle is lying, I have done nothing but treat everyone with respect. She has admitted to accusing mods of hating her but subsequently admitted to them doing a fair job of moderating. She even made up with a mod she accused of hating her. Additionally, she even stepped down from the server when she was mod because of reasons I did not agree with. Ultimately, I am saddened that this has even happened. We all worked hard to make this partnership happen, I have even been working on incentivicizing users (via gift cards, or other rewards) to edit and help in the wikia but if you wish to remove the affiliation then I respect the decision. I disagree vehemently but it is not my decision to make. I am honestly tired of this from her, she has an issue she then threatens to get the affiliation to be removed, she has to have her way, and it's frustrating. I have been respectful, I have tried doing something for the entire community but I will not be held hostage by her. I worked something out with you. Uncool is still there and still comments and interacts, Davjac who she considers a close friend doesn't agree with the accusation either. The records are there, she wasn't mistreated, she didn't like that there was a change implemented so she cried foul. - Spider-Man
On a minor note, I noticed that all quotations taken from the series are based on fan translations. Granted, there are many manga chapters and anime episodes that are without official translations and such, but for those who have been officially released in English, would it be out of the question to replace them with quotations from the Del Ray/Kodansha manga translations, if not the Funimation dub (though I feel it would be more ideal to use the manga, since that is what Fairy Tail primarily is), or would it be too much trouble?
 
  +
[[User:AstonishingSpiderMan|AstonishingSpiderMan]] ([[User talk:AstonishingSpiderMan|talk]]) 23:57, June 6, 2020 (UTC)
   
  +
I want to start off saying that in no way do users in the discord bully anyone. There is friendly banter yes, but to say we bullied someone into the point of leaving is 100% false. Next, Michelle and I are friends and in no way am I here to talk bad about her or anyone else for that matter. I am here to say yes, there were problems between people in the server, but it was never bullying. People didn't get along all that well sometimes and after some changes were made there were some issues that happened. Again, I am friends with Michelle and all the mods as well. I understand people were unhappy and were having a hard time that is literally just people not getting along all the time. Neither side was bullying the other. I am someone who tends to stay neutral which I will do now but really wanted to give another POV on this issue. I disagree with the statement that she was bullied out of the server 100% again and I do recognize there were issues between users which is bound to happen. The community and server are a good place and people are always having fun for the most part in their discussions and interactions with each other. I don't think it’s fair to punish everyone else revoking the affiliation over something where both parties were at fault for not getting along not bullying. Obviously, you probably don't care about my opinion or pov on the matter, but this is what happened. Not everyone is going to agree or get along all the time and it’s unfair to punish everyone else because of problems a few had with each other. Also, the post makes it seem like we are all bullies and rude which is not the case at all. These people are friends of mine on both sides. [[User:Taillee|Taillee]] ([[User talk:Taillee|talk]]) 01:31, June 7, 2020 (UTC)
I hope you will consider this proposition. [[User:Immblueversion|Immblueversion]] 17:18, October 18, 2011 (UTC)
 
   
  +
I wasn't going to make a statement because after i left the server that was the end of it for me. but i do want to clear some things up. the issues I had with the server stemmed from a select few individuals, and in no way reflects on the community as a whole. I won't be calling out or naming said individuals because honestly there isn't a need to - i still hold dearly to me many people from the server, a majority of which are part of the staff. the term bullying is not the most appropriate word for the conflicts that had occurred as i am not someone who is without fault. Nor was it a manner of outright harassment either.
See the discussion [[Forum:Should we use the official subtitle episode names by Funimation?|here]]. However, I'll try to add the FUNimation title on the template. {{User:Rauleli/Sig2}} 19:18, October 18, 2011 (UTC)
 
   
  +
However, i was not respected there, myself as well as many other people from the server have voiced the same opinions and thoughts. I was treated in a hurtful manner by people i considered friends to me or people who i had tried to make amends with.
I would be against using the Del Rey/Kodansha as well as the Funmation translations as I'm not familiar with them or how they are run. If they change something for censorship purposes or because they think some wording fits better than another then we would have incorrect translations on the site. {{User:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Sig3|21:06,10/18/2011}}
 
   
  +
if there is one thing i pride myself on, it is that i am a genuine person, it may appear as though i love to create drama but it is rather that i am someone who is not easily pushed around and i will always stand up for myself when i'm being treated poorly. I think a lot of people from the wiki could agree with that, as well as people from the server. Leaving the server was not a decision i took lightly and it is one i had sat on for a while and it is one that i didn't want to make, but ultimately i felt extremely uncomfortable remaining in a place where i felt nothing but hostility.
Well, if we're only limiting the importance of official translations to determine how character names are spelled, then I guess I slightly overestimated something here. [[User:Immblueversion|Immblueversion]] 00:37, October 19, 2011 (UTC)
 
   
  +
that's all i'm going to say on the matter because i have no need to drag this on any further, the decision to remove the affiliation was not a decision made or pushed solely by myself but was discussed by the admins themselves.
We use Kodansha for the name translations because Mashima does the english translation for those himself, however naturally he does not do the entire volumes, so... {{User:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Sig3|00:42,10/19/2011}}
 
   
  +
[[User:Michelle Hyena|Michelle Hyena]] ([[User talk:Michelle Hyena|talk]]) 02:10, June 7, 2020 (UTC)
== New dub actors? ==
 
 
As of yesterday, the first Fairy Tail Blu-ray/DVD box set has been released to those who pre-ordered it on the online shopping website "Right Stuf". According to those who obtained it (I am not one of them), the voice cast lists for episodes 4 and 12 have confirmed the English voices for two characters whose English voices were previously unknown: reportedly, [[Cancer]] is played by [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/people.php?id=75437 Will Short], and the young [[Gray Fullbuster]] is played by one [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/people.php?id=73124 Ryan Reynolds] (''not'' the live action actor; this Ryan Reynolds is a woman and a real Funimation voice actress). Should we wait for an actual video to be uploaded and verify these claims, or should I just go ahead and add these? [[User:Immblueversion|Immblueversion]] 02:00, October 20, 2011 (UTC)
 
 
Hmm... I think that'd be fine since it's just two characters. Though you are going to have to link us to one of these conversations before it can be done. {{User:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Sig3|02:40,10/20/2011}}
 
 
Unfortunately, this was via PMing on YouTube with a person who verified that s/he obtained a copy of the DVD by uploading a clip from an episode that has not been uploaded by Funimation previously. So unless there's a special method, I wouldn't be able to link you in any way I can think of. [[User:Immblueversion|Immblueversion]] 18:33, October 20, 2011 (UTC)
 
 
Would it at least be possible to link me to this person's youtube account so I can see the video? If so that should be enough for the change to be enacted. It's not that I think you are lying or anything, it's just it's always best to have at least some proof. {{User:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Sig3|22:01,10/20/2011}}
 
 
[http://www.youtube.com/user/Solatify Here] is the account of the user in question. You should find that the video is the only one the video has uploaded. If you were to also read the list of comments, you may find a comment posted by myself inquiring for some pieces of information via personal messaging. I use the same name for my YouTube account as I do here. [[User:Immblueversion|Immblueversion]] 00:02, October 21, 2011 (UTC)
 
 
Thanks, looks good enough to me, you may proceed with the changes. But please note that if they are incorrect <s>I'll hunt you down and kill you</s> i'll be upset ^_^. {{User:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Sig3|00:11,10/21/2011}}
 
 
== Minor cast announcement ==
 
 
[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A5nnPYufhgM This video interview] with Funimation dub ADV director Tyler Walker has confirmed that [[Jose Porla]] will be dubbed by Ed Blaylock (around the 14:50 mark). Permission to add him to the page?
 
 
Also, apparently there will be another cast reveal for those who are Elite Subscribers of Funimation. I am not one of those people, though. So if anyone else here were, could you please put them up once the reveal is made? I don't know how it will go down. [[User:Immblueversion|Immblueversion]] 02:38, November 22, 2011 (UTC)
 
 
yeah go ahead. {{User:Rauleli/Sig4}} 02:49, November 22, 2011 (UTC)
 
 
== Another cast confirmation ==
 
 
You need to be an Elite Subscriber of Funimation to view [http://www.funimation.com/fairy-tail/special/funimation-live-broadcast-interview-with-tyler-walker-adr-director-for-fairy-tail this site], but I can vouch that it reveals the following cast members:
 
 
Brina Palencia as Juvia<br>
 
David Wald as Gajeel<br>
 
Justin Cook as Totomaru
 
 
More as it develops, if it develops. [[User:Immblueversion|Immblueversion]] 01:44, November 24, 2011 (UTC)
 
 
==Character Portal==
 
I know that this is reviving a topic about a month ago, but were the changes reverted back? or are we being "dub friendly" (since the dub is being released. And anyway, why is Ikaruga on the front page anyway?. Shes been there for like 3 Episodes or 7 chapters (I guess), and wasn't the main antagonist of their arc either, in this case we would have Jellal, but he's been "gone" for who knows how long and is in a sense a protagonist since the Oracion Seis Arc.
 
 
[[User:Iqwertyier|Iqwertyier]] 09:35, November 24, 2011 (UTC)
 
 
Ikaruga is there to keep the female to male ratio as close as possible {{User:Rauleli/Sig4}} 12:49, November 24, 2011 (UTC)
 
 
== New name spellings (Volume 16) ==
 
 
I obtained the latest volume of Fairy Tail translated by Kondansha, and I noticed the following name changes (note that I don't have many of the other volumes, so I'm unaware if some of the changes may be legitimate; also, I'll check if I missed any):
 
 
*[[Charle]] is Carla
 
*[[Erigor]] is Eragor (may be a typo)
 
*[[Gatou]] is Gatô
 
*[[Iwan Dreyar]] is Ivan Dreyar
 
*[[Porlyusica]] is Poluchka
 
*[[Thunder God Tribe]] is Raijin Tribe
 
 
Also, I wanted to bring this up before, but where did the name [[Shitou Yajima]] come from? Reading over the raw manga scans of every volume and chapter his name is mentioned, he is only ever referred to as "Yajima." I ''have'' read the fan-translated chapter where his name is first mentioned, and it is spelled "Shitou." However, in the raw version of that chapter, it is spelled "Yajima." I was wondering if he underwent a name change from the magazine-printed chapter to the ''tankobon'' volume. (I must also note that the fan-translation of the same chapter listed [[Michello]]'s name as "Makalov," which may or may not have been a confusion with "Makarov.") If I can find the chapter in question, I'll post it later, for I do not have time at the moment. [[User:Immblueversion|Immblueversion]] 20:19, December 2, 2011 (UTC)
 
 
Erigor. Iwan and Thunder God Tribe have come from previous volumes, so I'm not sure if making any of thse changes would be the best idea. Plus, volume 16 was supposed to come out the 8th so how did you get it before the release date? {{User:Rauleli/Sig4}} 20:25, December 2, 2011 (UTC)
 
 
:''November'' 8 is when it came out. Today is ''December'' 2, the day I got it. Also, this is Kodansha that released it. But still... [[User:Immblueversion|Immblueversion]] 23:57, December 2, 2011 (UTC)
 
 
most of these are just tings that are reverted back to fan translations... im a bit confused as well. I know the distributors are different now, but how did the names change. {{User:Garyness/Signature}} 00:02, December 3, 2011 (UTC)
 
 
:So does this mean they ''won't'' be changed? At least the ones whose names have already been revealed? Because it's Kodansha that's translating the manga, plus it's releasing them in both Japan and North America. But I suppose I'd need a source saying they've received "official" translations from Hiro Mashima, because the volume doesn't contain that statement like the earlier volumes do, even when re-released by Kodansha. Though I do recall in Volume 1 where the translator states that when Happy calls himself the "Nekomander," s/he translated it as such, considering calling it "Kittymander" but then deciding "Nekomander" sounded better. While the Kodansha-released volume contains that very statement, it actually translates the name to "Kittymander." I've been wondering what you'd make of that. [[User:Immblueversion|Immblueversion]] 15:26, December 4, 2011 (UTC)
 
 
I won't say that they ''won't'' be changed, but at the moment we are going to leave them alone (except for Gatou). {{User:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Sig3|20:05,12/4/2011}}
 

Revision as of 02:10, 7 June 2020

Skip to Table of Contents
Wiki

This is the talk page for the article "Main Page".

  • This space is for discussing changes to the article. General discussion about the subject belongs in forums, and direct all questions to our Chat or Blogs.
  • Put new text under old text. Click here to start a new topic.
  • Please remember to stay civil and sign all of your comments with four tildes (~~~~).

Removal of the Reddit Discord

I'm writing this as a form of formality and documentation on the removal of the fairy tail reddit discord from the fairy tail wiki. Based on recent events, We are now ending our affiliation with the Fairy Tail reddit discord due to events brought up by User:Miskos3 as quoted below.

"Hello, so there has been a bit of, um, situation with the whole affiliation thing to the FT reddit and their discord. Basically, Michelle became a moderator in that discord, but ended up being constantly bullied by the rest of their staff and/or other people. Because of that, she decided to leave that server. Since as far as I'm concerned, I considered her as sort of a FT wiki representative in this whole affiliation thing, and in any kind of partnership, it looks quite bad to treat a person you're dealing with in such a manner."

When the idea of implementing the reddit discord in the fairy tail wiki was proposed by User:AstonishingSpiderMan, they've mentioned these "Ultimately like I said, I want to unite discord, reddit, and the ft wikia together where the fandom could coexist and prosper and thrive with our love for Fairy Tail."

We believe that the discord staffs and members bullying someone from the fairy tail wiki side does not fit with what was promised to us by User:AstonishingSpiderMan. This kind of treatment does not support the idea of "unity between reddit, discord and coexistence" As admins we have taken an executive decision to terminate the said partnership. LightningGeistRead about Laxus? 11:18, June 6, 2020 (UTC)

A shame that this happened, any word from AstonishingSpiderMan about this?Ophiuchus in ECS arc no bgAnimaltamer7Ophiuchus11:29, June 6, 2020 (UTC)

None so far, but given that the people from the fairy tail wiki are already in the minority within the discord its very likely that the majority of users will stick with their fellow reddit discord members. Bullying a moderator to the point of them leaving the discord server already means that bullying is agreed upon by a lot of users and such thing were allowed to happen by the rest of the discord. Even if the bullying was denounced by User:AstonishingSpiderMan it doesn't change the fact that such thing happened, and it's very unlikely that they can force the discord members to change their ways either.

So it's really unfortunate that the situation led to this and promoting a place where such bullying happens is not what we were hoping to accomplish in the said partnership and it is definitely not the place where we would encourage the young and new fans of the series visiting the wiki to be exposed to. LightningGeistRead about Laxus? 12:07, June 6, 2020 (UTC)

Michelle is lying, I have done nothing but treat everyone with respect. She has admitted to accusing mods of hating her but subsequently admitted to them doing a fair job of moderating. She even made up with a mod she accused of hating her. Additionally, she even stepped down from the server when she was mod because of reasons I did not agree with. Ultimately, I am saddened that this has even happened. We all worked hard to make this partnership happen, I have even been working on incentivicizing users (via gift cards, or other rewards) to edit and help in the wikia but if you wish to remove the affiliation then I respect the decision. I disagree vehemently but it is not my decision to make. I am honestly tired of this from her, she has an issue she then threatens to get the affiliation to be removed, she has to have her way, and it's frustrating. I have been respectful, I have tried doing something for the entire community but I will not be held hostage by her. I worked something out with you. Uncool is still there and still comments and interacts, Davjac who she considers a close friend doesn't agree with the accusation either. The records are there, she wasn't mistreated, she didn't like that there was a change implemented so she cried foul. - Spider-Man AstonishingSpiderMan (talk) 23:57, June 6, 2020 (UTC)

I want to start off saying that in no way do users in the discord bully anyone. There is friendly banter yes, but to say we bullied someone into the point of leaving is 100% false. Next, Michelle and I are friends and in no way am I here to talk bad about her or anyone else for that matter. I am here to say yes, there were problems between people in the server, but it was never bullying. People didn't get along all that well sometimes and after some changes were made there were some issues that happened. Again, I am friends with Michelle and all the mods as well. I understand people were unhappy and were having a hard time that is literally just people not getting along all the time. Neither side was bullying the other. I am someone who tends to stay neutral which I will do now but really wanted to give another POV on this issue. I disagree with the statement that she was bullied out of the server 100% again and I do recognize there were issues between users which is bound to happen. The community and server are a good place and people are always having fun for the most part in their discussions and interactions with each other. I don't think it’s fair to punish everyone else revoking the affiliation over something where both parties were at fault for not getting along not bullying. Obviously, you probably don't care about my opinion or pov on the matter, but this is what happened. Not everyone is going to agree or get along all the time and it’s unfair to punish everyone else because of problems a few had with each other. Also, the post makes it seem like we are all bullies and rude which is not the case at all. These people are friends of mine on both sides. Taillee (talk) 01:31, June 7, 2020 (UTC)

I wasn't going to make a statement because after i left the server that was the end of it for me. but i do want to clear some things up. the issues I had with the server stemmed from a select few individuals, and in no way reflects on the community as a whole. I won't be calling out or naming said individuals because honestly there isn't a need to - i still hold dearly to me many people from the server, a majority of which are part of the staff. the term bullying is not the most appropriate word for the conflicts that had occurred as i am not someone who is without fault. Nor was it a manner of outright harassment either.

However, i was not respected there, myself as well as many other people from the server have voiced the same opinions and thoughts. I was treated in a hurtful manner by people i considered friends to me or people who i had tried to make amends with.

if there is one thing i pride myself on, it is that i am a genuine person, it may appear as though i love to create drama but it is rather that i am someone who is not easily pushed around and i will always stand up for myself when i'm being treated poorly. I think a lot of people from the wiki could agree with that, as well as people from the server. Leaving the server was not a decision i took lightly and it is one i had sat on for a while and it is one that i didn't want to make, but ultimately i felt extremely uncomfortable remaining in a place where i felt nothing but hostility.

that's all i'm going to say on the matter because i have no need to drag this on any further, the decision to remove the affiliation was not a decision made or pushed solely by myself but was discussed by the admins themselves.

Michelle Hyena (talk) 02:10, June 7, 2020 (UTC)