| Skip to Table of Contents | |
|---|---|
|
This is the talk page for the article "Hanamaru".
|
Delete
Why is this listed as an enchantment ability? It just seemed like a generic Enchantment more than anything else. 夢Iam... 黒 JakuhōRaikōben死19:42,12/5/2016
Looking at Berserker being set up in a similar way, I'm about as confused. Can anyone explain to me the difference between an echantment ability and an echantment itself? I just don't understand why the named abilities have a category of its own somehow? Miskos3 Message 20:00, December 5, 2016 (UTC)
...I think we consider it named? Maybe we could wait for the raws to see the context as Irene is likely just mocking Erza by creating the pattern... but I'd still argue that it should have a page. I mean... we seem to take Lucy's kicks and punches seriously. >.> --Sane Lunatic (talk) 20:05, December 5, 2016 (UTC)
Oooooooooooooo I get it now. Yeah, I guess it is about as dumb as Fire Dragon's Roasting Bath... Miskos3 Message 20:07, December 5, 2016 (UTC)
But is it named tho? I viewed it as a generic name. The translation note on Mangastream said that Flower Circle is just what japanese teachers put on their students work when they do a good job. To me, that would be like the english equivalent of making a "Smiley Face" Enchantment page. >_> 夢Iam... 黒 JakuhōRaikōben死20:11,12/5/2016
*shrugs* I don't disagree. But in the same vein, I think it's ridiculous that we have pages describing non-magical kicks and punches simply because Lucy yelled, "Lucy Kick/Punch!" And I know many people don't agree with that. Which is not to say that they'd consider these two situations similar. I'd support deleting the page then. And Roasting Bath. ._./ --Sane Lunatic (talk) 20:19, December 5, 2016 (UTC)
@Flipsy Fuck you! No one makes fun of me!
\(•_•)
) )z
/ \
I'm fabulous! ^__^ 夢Iam... 黒 JakuhōRaikōben死20:20,12/5/2016
It's so-so imo. xP The way it is described right now, I'd not mind keeping it although I prefer the English translation, however, I can see why one would think it's not worth having a page. Also, I used to get a stamp of a bee in first grade, wish Irene would rearrange the swords into a bee... Miskos3 Message 20:20, December 5, 2016 (UTC)
Just leaving my two cents, but I think it's better deleted. The swords aren't hers; they're just rearranged so it's more of a Telekinesis than anything tbh Dispelling
Mage20:28,12/5/2016
I agree that this page should be deleted if it is just something Irene used to mock erza, what if irene said "Here's a smiley face for you" would that mean this wiki will create a smiley face page too?, but if this page wont be deleted i agree that this should be named Flower Circle coz if we retained its japanese name then all of the attacks and abilities in this wiki should be translated back to japanese for uniformity. LightningGeist
02:10, December 6, 2016 (UTC)
In what world is it even an enchantment? She was just goofing around (Erza's own paraphrased words). And once again, literal translations don't always work. It's like True-Ice Kamui. Or all of Ezel's swords. But regardless, it should have just been outright deleted. I would have done it had I gotten my hands on it first, but now we have a dumb discussion going...
Wrath
Zero 03:41, December 6, 2016 (UTC)
- Was gonna delete it outright, but Misk, Sane, and Nc were discussing it in the Wiki Activity. :P 夢Iam... 黒 JakuhōRaikōben死03:46,12/6/2016