User blog comment:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Chapter 355: Song of the Fairies, Review./@comment-5580383-20131010211846/@comment-5580383-20131010215533

Agreed 100% both in quality and quantity. Erza has much more sex appeal overall than Lucy( Not saying Lucy isn't hot though, she still is). Erza has that raw sexuaility that can rival Yoruichi, especially in the lack of modesty/perverted thoughts department, that and the hentai potency writes itself with Erza, especially how she still wishes to shower with Natsu and Gray despite the fact they're no longer kids.Erza is the hottest girl in Fairy Tail by far, though Kagura,Minevra and Mirajane give her a run for her money. Something about Erza gives her this pesudo MILF or Virgin Cougar appeal.

Yeah seeing Lucy naked is like seeing Gray naked, just another day at the office if you ask me.Lucy is hot but she doesn't have that  raw sex appeal as Erza, though when she's with other women( Cana, Juvia, Flare ,etc) Her hental potential jumps  up , esepciall for  some good old fashion Yuri.