User blog comment:Miskos3/Fairy Tail Chapter 368: The Third Seal, Review/@comment-7418318-20140124124020/@comment-7418318-20140124125505

If she's just controlling his body why did he say/think "To get you to give me back Lisanna, I will obliterate Fairy Tail".

Wouldn't he be thinking "No, I can't stop my body from killing my friends. Please forgive me." or something like that if it was just his body under Sayla's control?

As for Gildarts I'll be a bit lazy and just copy/paste when I wrote in the prediction blog: His appearance, his overwhelming power, the way he accidentally harmed an entire village, the way he apologized for it, the way he always looks slightly amused, the way he looks when that humor suddenly drops away, the way he just made a short flick with his hand to casually brush Natsu aside, that he knows Natsu, him being nice to Lisanna... it's all just the same way I imagine Gildarts would behave in this situation.

In my mind I know he can't be Gildarts, but somehow Silver still feels the same as Gildarts to me.