User blog comment:Real Godisme/Chapter 476 Review/@comment-4829046-20160307174930/@comment-7418318-20160307190844

I'd like to toss another aspect into the discussion:

In Edolas everyone lost their magic together and magic is only in their memories now.

In Earthland it's only Chelia who lost her magic and while everyone else will go on to live as if nothing has happened and she'll be constantly confronted with what she lost.

Now depending on her personality this can be either depressing or a warm reminder of good times. I know too little to about Chelia to judge that.