User blog comment:PUNCHURPREGNANT/Gray and Silver Predictions/@comment-7418318-20140125091239

Crazy, baseless theory incoming:

Silver is Edolas Gildarts!

After he came through an anima years ago he was frustrated that everyone in this world had magic and he needed magic items, so he made a packt with Tartarus and got turned into a Demon, which ended up giving him a magic container like other Earthland Mages.

The reason why he smells like and hates Gray is because in Edolas Gray Surge was the outcome of an affair which ended up destroying his marriage. Even though he knows that Gray Fullbuster is not Gray Surge, he still can't help but being disgusted by the name and the mental image it invokes.

I'll be laughing my ass off so badly if that really turns out true. :D