User blog comment:FairyRaven/Fairy Tail Chapter 335: The Time of Life, Review and Commentary/@comment-5840892-20130614190903/@comment-4829046-20130615063611

Well, its your opinion... To be factual, it seems that guns are more than enough to take out most regular mages according to the kidnappers in the GMG but we didn't really see that in effect.

But all things considered, the immortal FT cast vs. the humans in Index? That should never happen. There is a clear distinction and there are some series that must NEVER cross with another due to the MASSIVE difference between them. I just don't see the logic behind interactions between beings that have no internal power source nor indestructible bodies and beings that have magic(mana)/chakra/chi(ki)/spiritual power etc. and bodies that seem to be made of something more durable than carbon fiber.

I know the comedy factor plays a crucial role here but sometimes even when its supposed to be serious, Ft fails to deliver the actual effect(especially in the anime) while Index does. The FT cast is supposed to represent super power, they are on a different league from Index cast. Not saying that some of the Index cast can give some of them a run for their money.

The way things work is completely different. The Index verse doesn't depend solely on power but careful analysis and strategic timing and above all good knowledge of things, something most super power shounen don't really need to use.

This is why I say, they can't really be compared and I apologize for saying that either can be beaten.