User blog comment:Imhungry4444/Erza vs. Mirajane Fight Prediction/@comment-99.72.224.208-20130804042150

Erza seems majorly out of character. I doubt she would challenge Mira to fight like that. Also, she seems overly cocky. The real Erza acknowledges her weaknesses, which was definitely not portrayed in this character.

I think Erza versus Mirajane would end in something close to a draw, with maybe, maybe Erza just barely winning, but not such an overwhelming victory. Both are very strong-willed and powerful mages and even if one overpowered the other, they would still go on until they couldn't stand.