User blog comment:Jedred/WHO IS THAT GUY that looks kinda emo?/@comment-128.227.15.48-20100918073004/@comment-128.227.12.201-20100919030433

Yes he beat Lluvia, however she fell in love with him throughout the fight. In the end I don't think she fought with all of her strength. I just don't think from the fights we have seen that Gray is quite there. While he did beat Fukuro during the Tower of Heaven arc that was his only fight, during the Fighting Festival arc, he did not beat Bixlow, and during the Oración Seis arc, he could not beat Racer on his own. I am not saying that he should not be S-class, I am just saying from everything we have seen he is not as strong as the other S-class members. I think one, we have not seen all that Gray has to offer and two, he is not ready to be an S-class, yet. That is why I put him in the "might/should" group.