Forum:Tab Voting

Okay, this is a continuation of the forum here. It was decided that tabs would be added to the 5 longest pages on the site (Lucy, Natsu, Erza, Gray, and Happy), and now we are trying to determine what tabs we will included and what will go under those tabs. Please note you should vote for the tab that organizes the content in a way you would want the content organized, do not vote for a set of tabs because you like the design of the tabs! The design of the tabs are irrelevant because the winning organization will have its design changed to whatever the community wants it to be changed to! 23:35,9/23/2013

Requirements

 * All Administrators, Councilors, and Moderators are allowed to participate in the voting.
 * is allowed to vote. ( ._.) You're welcome.
 * Any users without user rights, must meet the following criteria:
 * Been an editor on this wiki for at least 3 months.
 * Have at least 300 mainspace article edits.
 * Any user suspected of using a sock account will not only have their sock account blocked indefinitely but will be blocked from editing for a minimum of 4 months! No exceptions.

Option 1
I think this is the best option, and no, not just because I was the one who proposed it. I suppose I'll give analysis of each option so that I can explain why I believe Option 1 is the best.
 * Option 1, in my opinion, is the most logical option. In the Main or "Overview" tab, it includes all of the general information about the character including the character's Personality, History, Magic and Abilities, etc. etc. The next tab is the Synopsis tab where all of the character's plot is listed. The Synopsis was extremely long and pretty much the main reason for us getting tabs so it stands to reason that it should have its own tab. The third tab is the Relationships tab, which, considering all the various relationships the main characters have made, definitely deserves its own tab. And lastly, is the Appearances in Other Media Tab. It, due to it currently being expanded by the Referencia Guild, has gotten extremely long, and without a doubt should stand on its own. Remember, the main point of tabs is so that pages are made shorter, easier to read, and easier to load.
 * Option 2 is the second best option on the list, in my opinion. Everything is ordered in a suitable fashion except for one little section - the History section. In Option 2, the History section is thrown with the Synopsis section. Which seems fine, but is actually kind of a problem. Firstly, the Synopsis is where we place all of the character's actions from the start of the series. The History section is the character's back story, things that happened to the character before the plot, so I believe it's only logical to place a character's back story on the Main tab with the rest of the general information about the character. Also, I don't really like having things in tabs if it's not mentioned in the tab title. If a tab says "Synopsis" then it should just have Synopsis, if it's going to include History then it should include history in the title. I don't want anyone to have to search for information when we implement the tabs.
 * Option 3 is not suitable, in my opinion, for several reasons. Firstly, it keeps the Synopsis on the Main tab. Synopsis is by far the largest part of Lucy's page, and is almost completely the reason we are having to do tabs in the first place. Keeping it on the Main Tab defeats the purpose of having Tabs. Secondly, Option 3 puts the Magic and Abilities on a separate tab. Aside from the fact that I believe Magic and Abilities is more logically placed on the Main Tab, giving it it's on tab causes a serious issue for one of our pages: Happy. His Magic and Abilities is extremely short with only few short paragraphs . So, if Magic and Abilities had its own tab, Happy would have a tab with only a few paragraphs on it, which, needless to say, would look terrible.
 * Option 4 is also not suitable for several reasons. Firstly, as I previously mentioned, Synopsis is by far the largest portion of not only Lucy's page, but every main character's page. So why, when we are trying to cut down on the page's loading time, would we mix Synopsis (the longest portion) with Appearance in Other Media (the second longest portion)? It makes no sense, and completely takes away the point of tabs. In addition to this, Option 4, like Option 3, has Magic and Abilities as a separate tab and I mentioned the issues with doing that in my analysis of Option 3. Also, the order of the tabs is just awkward. :/
 * Option 5 is... weird ( ._.) and also not suitable. Firstly, the ordering and the grouping of the tabs in general is just...weird. Main, Extra, Other just seems a bit awkward and is very unspecific. Secondly, Synopsis is placed on the Main tab, which, as I mentioned earlier, I believe is not a good idea. Thirdly, Magic & Abilities is placed in the "Extras" tab, which seems inaccurate to me. A character's Magic & Abilities is an extremely important part of who they are. Labeling it an "Extra" and throwing it in with Trivia and Quotes seems a little erroneous in my opinion. There's also the "Other" tab which is just an awkward mash up of the relationships and Appearances and Other Media - it seems lazy. Now obviously the person who thought this tab system up wasn't being lazy, but anyone who visited our wiki wouldn't know that and if they saw the tabs ordered like that - I'm positive they would think so.

I said a mouthful. ( ._.) But essentially, that's my reasoning behind voting for Option 1. 23:35,9/23/2013