User blog comment:SoulRise99/HISHE: How Fairy Tail Should Have Ended/@comment-7418318-20170725060042/@comment-7418318-20170725123931

Yeah, this time we are on the same page regarding opinion, hence my putting "to me" there.

But to elaborate a bit: I can enjoy unhappy endings as much as the next guy (as weird as that might sound). I loved the FFX ending, Madoka, Code Geass and most recently SukaSuka, all of which had bittersweet endings.

But I have two issues with your proposal. First of all it wouldn't even be bittersweet because you suggest that everyone in FT should be killed. That would just be sad and depressing. And more importantly, Fairy Tail is a far more upbeat and lighthearted series. I have (or rather had... gotta get used to taking about the manga in past tense) no problem with it going dark and serious temporarily, but to me it should absolutely not end that way. Yeah, the ending might have been a bit too upbeat and too free of consequences, but I prefer that over "everyone dies". That would have felt like a betrayal of what Fairy Tail both as a guild and a series stand for.