User blog comment:ChaosKnight/Manga, manga, everywhere.../@comment-16344653-20111123053958/@comment-3290324-20111123055003

I disagree. I don't think he's trying to make Ukitake evil. The entire situation in itself is no where near evil so even if Ukitake did give Ichigo the badge for those intentions it wouldn't really be a big deal. This chapter was bad simply because the "big revelation" wasn't big at all.