User blog comment:Panemorfos/Strongest Fairy Tail characters up to chapter 470/@comment-112.204.58.91-20160130050545/@comment-27281341-20160130211923

I believe that, yes, Lucy is above Juvia. Her new power say so. She has higher Attack Power by a lot, is more versatile by a long shot and she has the numbers by her side. Juvia is better defensively and faster with better range and AoE, but her low attack power and the fact that all of her attacks are quite predictable give Lucy the victory.