User blog comment:CNBA3/Neinhart = Simon Theory?/@comment-1153699-20160211055931/@comment-1153699-20160213175936

@Wrath, lol. Not everyone analyzed the silhouettes of all the Spriggan 12 you know..

Well, if you're talking about her (assuming it's actually a female and not Mard 2.0 or something), I can't honestly sit here and say "There's no way she's Juvia's cousin. It's impossible. Completely". Why? Because I'm not Hiro. It's one heck of a shot in the dark if you ask me but if you wanna believe that, go ahead.

We don't have any evidence to prove whether she really is her cousin or not. Like.. At all. She could even be one of Gildarts's ex-girlfriends. We don't know.

But saying that silhouette is Juvia's cousin isn't really the same as saying Neinhart is Erza's relative. Erza & Kagura are heading off to fight Neinhart (someone who has been hyped for quite a while). His theme also seems to be about weapons, much like Erza (and Kagura). Meanwhile, That 3rd female isn't even in the same area as Juvia's team and we pretty much know nothing about her.

My prediction is also a shot in the dark I guess. But that's what predictions are, aren't they? Shots in the dark.

@Misk, um... What?

@NNN, I wasn't comparing Simon with Lisanna. I was comparing her (and Silver) with Erza's "dead" parents.

Erza's parents being dead isn't 100% confirmed. Hiro never said how they "died" or what happened to them. But even if they are dead, it doesn't mean Hiro can't bring one of them back. Both Lisanna and Silver were said to be dead. Later it turned out Lisanna didn't acutally die. Silver did die, but Hiro wanted to bring him back for an arc so he did, and came up with some reason later. What's stopping Hiro from doing the same thing now?