User blog comment:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Chapter 480: The Northern Gravestone, Review./@comment-100.15.97.117-20160407211155/@comment-4829046-20160408041754

A tie? Hell no. Kagura was left speechless, after which she had to be saved from a freaking pillar and then Erza made her break down emotionally. That's a defeat by shounen logic. Plus if Minerva was out of the equation and they had continued fighting without that emotional moment, she would've just used second origin(a.k.a. nakama armour a.k.a. armour that breaks logic) to OHKO.

The anon is right, but ironically, because he is right, Kagura can't win XP