User blog comment:TheCarrotSaysYumYum/Dragons, People and Demons.../@comment-4047931-20120726220705

Well here are my thoughts about this theory. To be honest here I have mixed feelings about this theory. Some points are good yet others I find are rather dull and bad but that’s. Needless to say though it is well written and you referencing of past events do a good job to backing up the points made here. I split it up so there is a little paragraph for each paragraph YumYum did so try line them up. Now with that out of the way I can go into detail now. *About Zeref reacting to Zancrow wouldn’t be just because of the dark natures of Ultear and Zancrow with Ultear caring little about everyone’s but her own happiness and Zancrow’s lack of care for the life of others. Personally I think because of this encounter with these and seeing the personalities made lose his grip on his peaceful self. Well that’s pretty much all I have to say about it. I hope it’s not too messy and there are bit’s about what I personally think might so yeah and I'm not saying any ideas of mine are better.
 * First of all I love the idea off men battling the dragons battling in the past. The feel of pride that would come from besting these mighty beasts and the clash of powers between the two forces seeing that the human who would have to have a great amount of to face up against a dragon would be awesome. Just thinking about makes me feel exited but do believe that dragons would be classed as incredibly powerful beasts even if they lost a few battles to the humans. I still love the idea of powerful Mages battling against Dragons and honestly I think these battles would a have determined who would become Dragon Slayers or not, be it the dragons being pleased in the power of the human who stood against it or the rare occurrence of the dragons being defeated in battle.
 * Now about the demons. I enjoy the idea demons battling dragons and I would agree with the demons would lose. The demons appearing all around the world seems reasonable seeing that they would appear were Zeref had been and I do like thinking that Zeref would have killed a few dragons explaining why the dragons pay very close attention to him but my problems with this part is your idea for Zeref's motives to attacking the dragons and Acnologia following the demons and absorbing them seems a little too silly for my liking. I mean there was no reason mentioned for the demons surfacing, which I would say came into creation to help Zeref concur the world or eliminate humanity after Zeref saw it's darker side so he believed if he took over or destroyed humanity creating a world where the evil he saw wouldn't have to exist (maybe were the original idea of the Ultimate Magic World comes into play) and only the ones he sees fit will survive. Also if he did have a hate for humans maybe her created a mutually beneficial relationship earlier on is his life before he began creating demons with the Black Dragon: Acnologia with their hate for humans gives a slight reason to why his demons look a bit similar to the dragon as he may have based their design on the black dragon (well the nemesis demons) and how Zeref was able to summon it.
 * Now the idea for dragons freely teaching their magic is cool and the fear of Zeref is a very good motive and I completely agree that Natsu and Gajeel's magic was why they couldn't escape Freed's runes in the Fight Festival arc. Magic is alive you know.
 * So with the Dragon Slayers hunting down the demons would that be massive battle Zeref saw causing him to learn the importance of life? Also seeing that Deliora was still alive kind of states that the demons would have been very strong because if the dragons were attacking the demons, types like Deliora would at least be able to stand against them and live. Now about Mavis I don't like the idea of her being a dragon slayer one bit, mainly because there would be a few too many for my liking (I think she's a fairy hiding her tail) and what type would she be? I also don't think Lumen Histoire is used to seal Zeref's darkness and power away. Mainly because Zeref was able to use his powers on his own accord, even to go far as summon Acnologia itself. If anything I guess Lumen Histoire is some sort of failsafe or something for dark times even though it would be interesting if some of Zeref’s powers were hidden in it.
 * This next point is quite interesting as if Mavis and Zeref where actually friends and if Zeref was staying at the guild momentarily in would kind of explain how Hades knew where to look for Zeref and what he would look like.
 * I really think Mavis wouldn’t have been killed by Zeref especially knowing he values life and there would be reason for him to snap like that.
 * I really don’t have anything to say about the lack of care for Lumen Histoire.
 * So this next part would take place around the year 777 right? Well the God Slayers would have learned these abilities from Zeref’s teachings but the thing bugging me is saying the dragons would be hiding. I think that would be the last things dragons would do when faced with an opponent. That’s just me though. By the way how would the dragons know about Lumen Histoire? Wouldn’t Mavis only tell the secret to her most trusted friends AKA Purehito.
 * How would Makarov become the guild master around the time Layla died? And about the 3 Dragon Slayers in Fairy Tail, I believe it would just be a warning for what was going to happen in Edolas.
 * I don’t like idea of Zeref killing Hades because of his knowledge because wouldn’t that make him have to kill the others of Grimore Heart seeing they would all know a fair amount about Zeref. I like fact that Zeref was doing justice for the things Hades had done. Also I kind of feel Acnologia would be more an omen for Zeref’s return and a disaster approaching.
 * With seven years past I like your idea of the king being tricked into holding the GMG to take his eye off Arcadios’s plot for Zeref, but I don’t think it is would be used to bring the dragons back from the dimension they were put into as I find that the dragons being intelligent creatures wouldn’t get themselves stuck by their own plan. Also if they were all stuck in a different dimension how would Rogue and Sting learn their magic? They basically stated they were roughly children when they looked up to Gajeel and Natsu. With the plan I’d say that the eclipse plan would just Acradious enough power to take down the Dragon King as the festival could be a moment were the dragons return and I personally see them as a guardian race protecting the world but Zeref would have trouble bringing forth a new era with the dragons in his way so I guess it would be simple to use an incredibly powerful magic to do so.
 * You know with Mavis following her former guild about any history she had with Zeref or at least Makarov.
 * And I got nothing to say about Raven Tail and Lumen Histoire being darkness or light and about where we are now.