Fairy Tail Wiki talk:Referencia Guild/Archive 3

Jana

 * Welcome to the guild! 06:13,7/1/2012

Joining
Hi there! Your application looks good, though your inexperience in referencing seems to be an issue. If you need any help with that, just read our Referencing Guidelines here. If you still need help, don't be afraid to ask questions. Lastly...

Welcome to the Guild!!

KillingMeSoftly
Hello. Your application looks decent, though the fact that you don't have much experience in referencing and because you don't have a very... specific reason for wanting to join, it may be a problem. However, since you have been on Wikia for a lengthy amount of time, it's assumed that you are at least versatile in regular editing, which is good since the guild is now also working on article improvement. Practice with some referencing to get a good grasp on the matter before doing anything major. Also...

Welcome to the guild!
 * I'm accepted?! WOOHOO!!! Thanks so much!! I'll try my hardest and I promise, promise, promise that I won't disappoint you! ♥

Application
Hi there! Your edits look good so far and your skill in referencing looks acceptable, so welcome to the guild!

Applying
Hi there! Firstly, apologizes for a late response. >_< Second, you seen to have experience with referencing which is good and since you've been on wikia for a while that's even better. So, in other words, welcome to the guild!

Admission
Hi there! You seem to have good knowledge in referencing so welcome to the guild!

Application
I think you'd make a great edition to the guild, welcome! I'll add your name to the registry. 22:40,8/3/2012

FallenShadow's Application.
We have the guidelines written on the Project page on how to reference, which I was hoping you read through before applying. You don't need to join a Guild or Team to contribute to the wiki and also, you don't appear to edit a lot on the wiki anyhow. Sorry, but edit more and gain a little experience before applying again. Thank you. Okay then, Thanks anyway. 00:27, August 7, 2012 (UTC)

Application
Hey there! Saying you "could" say yes shows skepticism, though we do have referencing guidelines on the Guild page so you most likely will learn more from that. Anyways, welcome to the Guild. I'll add your name... soon. :P

Well yea. Before I posted my application I read the referencing guidelines that's why I said 'Yes'. And thanks for the welcoming! :)

Nalle's Application
You only joined Wikia approximately 20 days ago. In addition, you lack any experience in referencing and the fact that you want to join "because it's awesome" is a strong oppose to your request. It doesn't tell me that you're necessarily interested in contributing to the wiki while also being a part of a Site Guild. Edit some more, gain experience in references, and then feel free to reapply. Otherwise, I'm afraid we can't accept you right now.

i understand what you mean...and i really want to edit some references not also because its awesome, i really want to help ft wiki^_^...and i really promise to gain some experience in referencing>.<well Thank very much07:38, September 2, 2012 (UTC)

Pages which needs to be referenced
These may be minor, maybe your guild can add these up for future jobs, or if you have them in stored then ignore me.


 * 1) Gate of the Lion Key
 * 2) The Giant's Armor
 * 3) Flight Armor
 * 4) Illusion Magic
 * 5) Fortune Telling

Best Regards,

18:10,9/9/2012
 * We'll keep it in mind. Thanks for the suggestions, Kokoro! :)

Application
Sorry, but I'm going to have to turn down your application. Since joining this wiki last month, not one year ago, all of your edits have been towards a blog post you made. You did not answer the question on whether you know how to reference, which tells me you don't know, even though it's in our guidelines on the main Guild page. I wouldn't accept a complete newbie in actual wiki editing in the Guild. I do apologize.

Re-Joining
I'm going to have to turn down your application. While I have no reason to oppose you for being a good editor or for having skill in referencing, looking at your past edits here on the wiki you've only made 9 article edits, with the latest being in February of this year. In addition, edits you've made like this aren't really acceptable. Make more article edits on the wiki and feel free to reapply. But for now, I don't think I can accept you.

Some suggestions
Hello, I'm just here to pass on the names of some pages that could use referencing and/or expansion.

1. Great_Tree_Arc 2. Silfarion 07:17, October 4, 2012 (UTC)

Application
Cutting it short just because I'm tired of writing relatively thick messages at the moment, welcome to the Guild.

Heeeeeey! :D
I'm afraid I'll have to decline your application. A majority, if not all, of your current mainspace edits are simply to add interwiki links. That doesn't necessarily show much of your editing skills at the moment. On another note, just to make it clear, no, not everything is based on references. I guess if I write a summary describing how Natsu looks unreferenced would not be true then, huh? :P Make a couple other edits that aren't just interwiki, perhaps some referencing, and I'll reconsider.

Application
Welcome to the Guild. :P

FeaturedMe
Welcome to the guild! 23:09,11/9/2012

Laven Heartfilla
Welcome to the guild! 23:10,11/9/2012

Umnei
Welcome to the guild!! 22:08,11/12/2012

Joining
Welcome to the guild and sorry for the delay. 03:01,12/8/2012

XxxFairyTailRocksxxx Application
Welcome to the guild!!! 21:18,12/21/2012

RinRin's application
Welcome to the guild!!! 21:14,12/21/2012

Sweet won't let you down! 21:16, December 21, 2012 (UTC)

You'd better not. ;) 21:21,12/21/2012

Mint's Application
In the 2+ months that you have been on this wiki, you've only made five edits to articles and a majority of them being simple grammar mistakes that can be fixed by just about any user. Even if you do say you have knowledge with referencing, I'm afraid that with your apparent lack of experience with editing alone isn't yet suitable for the Referencia Guild at this moment. I advise making more edits on a regular basis and then reapply here. Depending on how much improvement is made since your last application, you may be considered to join the Guild.

Application
Hello. I'm afraid that I'll have to decline your application to the Guild. You have only a minimal amount of edits here and almost all of them are either grammar edits or just changes to the Image Galleries, which is also your main work on your other wiki, as well. Furthermore, I do not see that you have experience with referencing. Make more edits to articles here and reapply again. Your work will be evaluated again and it will be determined whether you are then suitable to join this Guild.