User blog comment:Imhungry4444/Above and beyond/@comment-16344653-20111024153411/@comment-16344653-20111024161220

Yes, he has beaten S-Class Mages because in other guilds their level needed to be S-Class is different than in Fairy Tail's because as I already stated above ""S-Class" are just the strongest members of a guild, there is no "law" that affects all the Magic Guilds to determine S-Class"