User blog comment:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Chapter 458: Morning Star, Review./@comment-1776824-20151026035039/@comment-1776824-20151026040655

Okay, I have to add that I don't hope she's out of commission for the entire war. Just maybe like...a good chunk?

Also, magic affecting durability has absolutely 0 to do with the fact that they are 100% human with human composition, and that human composition means water is essential to life as humans are 2/3 water. Can Erza tank stuff because of the magic in her body? Yeah okay, she can. When Erza is dehydrated to the point where death is a prospect, should she be able to move function and fight as normal? Not really. It's just an arguably dumbed down version of she has no sense and can still fight. What should've happened was that crippled her, and then her and Ajeel both took the Jupiter blast head on, knocking them both out for some time to come. That would've made for a much better fight imo.