User blog comment:Real Godisme/Chapter 481/@comment-5233713-20160413204031/@comment-7418318-20160413215113

Not really.

Sure what happened to her back then was bad, but ended with a very good moment for her, when she bonded with Lucy, so that memory isn't all bad for Juvia.

Keith on the other hand was far worse for her, since she wasn't just hurt, but ended up having to hurt the one she loves, making it double traumatic with barely eny redemptive factors.