User blog comment:Nerdyanimegirl225/The 3 picks/@comment-24066070-20140514105733

1) Natsu is too thick headed to get anything serious going.

2) Macao, since he guided the guild through seven harsh years. Furthermore, he's one of the senior members of the guild, so he likely has some wisdom, common sense and experience which is required to guide a guild.

The fact that he's always loitering around in the guild building also makes it easier for him to deal with matters when they arise, whereas Laxus and especially Gildarts are always away on missions. Besides, Macao being Master would still allow Laxus or Gildarts to participate in the Grand Magic Games if they would ever be reinstated. Sabertooth faces the problem that Sting can no longer participate now that he's Master, unless he would temporarily give the title to some random member.

3) Meanest, most twisted enemy would be Minerva in my opinion. Most horrible villain, in the sense of being a pathetic villain, would certainly be Crawford. I mean, how bloody retarded can you be?