User blog comment:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Chapter 424: Avatar, Review./@comment-85.229.47.162-20150316112409/@comment-25111584-20150317135216

Maybe read ToH arc again and you'll see that Juvia's love for Gray didn't really stop her from being a pretty cool character. The current Juvia goes way overboard. Most of the times, she's relegated to gags duty.

The only two good moments she ever had was against Meredy and Keith. But even against Meredy, the battle was finally Power of Feelings. Only against Keith did she really use any sort of strategy. Outside of battles, she keeps fangirling over Gray. He's her Sun? But what about her own dignity? Do you realize how undignified she looks when in her fangirl mode? She appears to have no personality without Gray.

What about Juvia herself? Why does she conjure rain? What is her personality like when she is not talking about Gray? It's been a long time since we saw her in such interactions, and it's not because of a lack of appearances.

Also, the point of my first post was that Juvia's initial attraction towards Gray was pure lust. It has obviously changed as the series has proceeded, but the lust is still a huge part of it. These are all traits of a pretty psychotic yandere ... yet her yandere mode is completely comic. Psychosis is not comic. But won't complain as this isn't really FT style. :P It still seems a bit like a halfway effort though.

This is her character and we shouldn't complain about it? When did we ever say that she was acting OOC? But why shouldn't we complain when a character is so monotonous, especially when it showed such great potential before? And, now, if Juvia does ever act sane, it's going to seem quite OOC. It'll be quite difficult to improve her now, though Mashima might still pull it off. In other words, she has been completely stereotyped. That's not a good thing.

Sorry, but what's AOT Cluth? O.o *is a noob* T_T