User blog comment:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Chapter 493: The White Dragneel, Review./@comment-4449950-20160713020037/@comment-7418318-20160714114000

I don't want Irene redeemed. We already have far too many redeemed characters in FT and even in this very arc Brandish has already gone through the whole bad act -> sob story -> redemption thing and is more on the FT side by now then on Alvarez.

I want Irene to either be killed or sent back to the other continent the way she is.

From Erza's side it would also be refreshing. All the reunions with the enstranged relatives so far ended on more of less good notes. The closest we have for not-good notes is Lucy, who's father died before they could fully reconcile, though even that was kind of done through that last letter.

Just once I want to have an evil relative that is rejected by the FT member and sent packing, instead of the cliché redemption we've gone through time and time again.