User blog comment:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Chapter 231: Terminator, Review./@comment-3061966-20110419031323/@comment-3061966-20110419035800

Lol Well we all have similar questions. It's possible he was part of FT and is part of Gildarts generation, the Hades comment is what fuels that speculation. Why? Maybe he wants more freedom, something a dark guild can give a person.

It may be a test. Maybe he just expected too much out his daughter, if she is indeed his kid.