User blog comment:IamJakuhoRaikoben/Chapter 398: The Final Duels, Review./@comment-4489126-20140902003802/@comment-7418318-20140903091302

I absolutely agree with Raven and Mega here.

Fanboying aside, Lucy's battles are much more intersting because the outcome isn't fixed from the start. With Erza it's almost asured that at some point she'll switch to the firepants and then win all on her own.

With Lucy we don't know how she'll fight, if someone jumps in to help (or steal the fight... -_- ) or if she'll even win at all.

When was the last time you were really surprised by something that Erza did during a battle? For me that's discarding her armour during the Ikaruga fight.

With Lucy on the other hand there's almost always something surprising happening. And in her last fight there were even three big surprised: Tripple summoning, summoning the Spirit King and being granted Aquarius' powers.

So even if I liked Erza more as a character, I'm still very sure that I'd like Lucy's fights more than Erza's.